Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dov Jacobson's avatar

The uncanny valley is made especially jagged by the weird idea that the AI we want is the one that most convincingly mimics human individuals.

Let us see the face of AI - not a mask. We will be much more comfortable with AI coworkers when they stop pretending they are us. When they take themselves seriously, so will we.

Expand full comment
Sylvie Lachize's avatar

As a UX practioner, the sample usability test report page strikes me as poor. During usability tests, we typically ask participants to carry out tasks on the website, and we report what went well and what didn't go so well (and we usually find a lot of irritants, none of which are reported by Claude on their so-called "report"). For the fun of it, I went to the Walmart site to try to find pillar candles for Christmas. I started on the French site (I am a francophone). I got confused by the home page which offers different ways to access the Xmas selection. I tried one, couldn't find what I was looking for and resorted to searching. I tried different seach terms but none gave me what I wanted. There's no autocorrect, so one of my searches came back empty because of a typo. So I switched to English because I know the exact term for the candles I am looking for ("pillar candles") and finally found what I was looking for. By then I was pretty frustrated. I guess to the non-expert, the Claude usability test report can pass as the real thing (you deem it as "quite solid", which is frightening!), but it is very unlikely to give you any real insight into what your users really do on your website. I would be more impressed if you managed to make Claude 1- come up with 5 unique usability sessions (simulating five different participants) on a very specific task such as "finding four quality unscented pillar candles for Christmas", highlighting both what went well and what didn't go well for each participant and 2- create a report accurately synthesizing the five sessions, ranking the usability problems by frequency and severity.

Expand full comment
60 more comments...

No posts